MOUNTAIN VIEWS STAR MAIL
Home » Opinion » Clones are people too

Clones are people too

Elio

Starring Yonas Kibreab, Remy Edgerly and Zoe Saldaña

PG

3.75/5

Elio is a touching, visually resplendent sci-fi family adventure that doesn’t fully realise its own disturbing implications.

After achieving his lifelong dream of being abducted by aliens, eleven-year old Elio Solis (Yonas Kibreab) must save the Communiverse, an interstellar diplomatic organisation, from a warlord’s wrath.

Elio is a cute, swiftly-paced adventure with endearing characters and truly stunning art direction.

The vibrant Communiverse headquarters brings to mind the Citadel in the Mass Effect games and the Ouster Swarm from Dan Simmons’ Hyperion novels, and the computer-generated presentation allows the filmmakers to cut loose with truly alien character designs, as opposed to humanoids with odd complexions or foreheads in so much other sci-fi.

In a possible nod to the first Star Trek movie, Elio’s plot cleverly uses the Voyager 1 space-probe and its famous golden record as the springboard for Elio’s interest in aliens, though I wish Voyager remained relevant beyond the first act.

While Elio is kind, loyal and determined, he has very little character development, experiences no lasting consequences for lying to the Communiverse, and his self-reflection on whether he was the unruly, obsessive problem on Earth holds little weight when he was right all along about the existence of aliens.

Elio quickly befriends Glordon (Remy Edgerly), the compassionate prince of a warlike race, and his arc of not wanting to follow in his brutal father’s footsteps is much more interesting than Elio’s journey.

The plot also uses cloning for subterfuge, and feels flippant in how it treats these near-indistinguishable copies with their own consciousnesses; a father technically kills his own son, and you wonder how this didn’t occur to the filmmakers.

If you can ignore the existential terrors the film raises, Elio is an energetic, moving and visually breathtaking family film currently playing at the Memorial Hall.

– Seth Lukas Hynes

Digital Editions


More News

  • For a lifetime of devotion

    For a lifetime of devotion

    One of the Yarra River’s most determined protectors, Gordon Buller, received the Mayor’s Lifetime Achievement Award for the Australia Day Civic Awards. Mr Buller was recognised for his tireless commitment…

  • Community leader recognised

    Community leader recognised

    A dedicated Hills community volunteer has been recognised for his long-standing commitment to connection, wellbeing and inclusion. Mr Heath Pawley was set to receive the Ian De La Rue Award…

  • Manosphere school fears

    Manosphere school fears

    The concerning rise of misogynistic behaviour among young men has been brought to the fore as school returns in the Yarra Ranges for 2026. It’s a trend documented by many…

  • Call for investigatio

    Call for investigatio

    Councillor Jim Child has called on the Yarra Ranges Council for a formal investigation into a reverse vending machine over beliefs it may be breaching its permit conditions. The O’Shannassy…

  • Pat lands achiever award

    Pat lands achiever award

    What started as a small way of reducing food and flower waste going to landfill evolved into something far beyond Patrick Natoli’s expectations. Co-founder and president of the Montrose Community…

  • Ausnet delayed in fixing Coldstream power outage

    Ausnet delayed in fixing Coldstream power outage

    A power outage in Coldstream affecting 143 customers is yet to be remedied after being reported at 5.41pm on Tuuesday 27 january. Ausnet initially expected a response team to arrive…

  • Heroes thanked

    Heroes thanked

    Fiona Waters from Bentleigh reached out to the Star Mail to share a heart-warming act of kindness from locals in Yarra Glen. I just wanted to do a shout out…

  • Call to restore growth fund

    Call to restore growth fund

    An ongoing push for the State Government to restore the Growing Suburbs Fund which supported tens of millions of dollars in infrastructure projects in Yarra Ranges and Cardinia is continuing.…

  • Healesville lifted in heat

    Healesville lifted in heat

    Tuesdays First Side played away at Croydon who were fourth on the ladder and we were languishing at the bottom of the ladder so we had our work cut out…

  • Triple-header win

    Triple-header win

    In the midweek pennant, Side One in Division Two faced the current ladder leaders in Upwey Tecoma at home. As well as being strong on the green, Upwey Tecoma are…